Me Him Her

Luke Bracey

Brendan

Dustin Milligan

Cory

Emily Meade

Gabbi

Haley Joel Osment

Geena Davis

Mrs. Ehrlick

Alia Shawkat

Laura

Casey Wilson

Jake McDorman

Griffin

Scott Bakula

Mr. Ehrlick

Angela Sarafyan

Heather

Kyle Bornheimer

Steve

Rebecca Drysdale

Kris

Zena Grey

Pixie Girl

Miles Fisher

Hunter Elizabeth

Hot Teen Girl

Max Landis

Party Bystander

Matt Cohen

Nug Nug Junior (uncredited)

Kelli Barksdale

Hot Teen Driver (uncredited)

Ashley McCarthy

Hot Girl in Car (uncredited)

Kristina Hess

Hot Girl in Car (uncredited)