Sins of the Preacher

Gail O'Grady

Susan Parker

Chris Gartin

Andrew Martin

James McDaniel

Wade Thompson

Taylor Cole

Brianna Daniels

Sarah Cote

Laura

Erin Cole

Casey Foreman

Chuck Case III

Courtroom Spectator / Church Mourner

Michael Cognata

Police Officer

Paula Plum

Kathy

Bree Williamson

Debbie Martin

Bates Wilder

George Wilder

Olivia Venuto

Heather Martin

Celeste Oliva

Mary Stone

Georgia Lyman

Leslie Davis

John Kooi

Chief Richards

Tom Kemp

Tom Parker

Katie Iacomini

Kristy Martin

Russell J. Gannon

Church Deacon

Mark DeAngelis

Pastor

Mark Anthony Del Negro

Court Clerk (uncredited)