When You Wish Upon a Pickle: A Sesame Street Special

Christopher Knowings

Chris

Suki Lopez

Nina

Ryan Dillon

Elmo

Peter Linz

Ernie / Herry Monster

Eric Jacobson

Bert / Grover / Oscar / Guy Smiley

David Rudman

Cookie Monster

Leslie Carrara-Rudolph

Abby Cadabby

Stephanie D'Abruzzo

Gale Warning

Matt Vogel

Wish Pickle / Mr. Johnson / Big Bird / The Count

Amanda Seyfried

Natalie Neptune

Blake Lively

Delivery Person

Ilana Glazer

Ms. Noodle

Jennifer Barnhart

Zoe / Gladys the Cow

Pam Arciero

Grundgetta / Shoes / Jacket

Justiin A. Davis

Self

Deborah Grausman

Smartie

Tyler Bunch

Frankie Cordero

John E. Kennedy

Carmen Osbahr